Utilitarianism was a bourgeois reformist movement that predated modern social democracy. In his major book of economic theory, capital, marx adopted the subsistence theory of wages the iron law propounded by the classical economists, and the labor theory of value, which asserted that the value of any manufactured item. This bloody orgy was a pure exercise in class genocide, asserts stephane courtois, the extrotskyite editor of the black book and historian of the french communist party, a reign of political carnage of planetary dimensions, a massacre designed to create a moral society through the extermination of the impure, through the silencing of any. Utilitarianism, introduced by jeremy bentham, is where people judge ideas and products by their usefulness. A philosophy that bases the moral worth of an action upon the number of people it gives happiness or pleasure to. Criticisms of consequentialism 916 and 918 criticisms of. Few, if any, have read the book, the black book of communism, and even if you pointed out this book, along with other historically accurate books, these overeducated idiots praising. Yet austere though this inventory is, its cumulative impact is overwhelming. The black book of communism alleges that communism killed 94 million people during the 20th century. Unlike the latter work, le livre noir du capitalismes primary goal is not to try to attribute a number of victims to the political system in question. Criticism of socialism is any critique of socialist models of economic organization and their feasibility as well as the political and social implications of adopting such a system. If these two approaches are combined, encouraging a small sector of society to become immensely wealthy increases the financial benefit to the general population, and therefore their pleasure, and as such their greed is entirely ethical.
The black book of communism crimes, terror, repression stephane courtois nicolas werth jeanlouis panne andrzej paczkowski karel bartosek jeanlouis margolin harvard university press cambridge, massachusetts london, england 1999 translated by jonathan murphy and mark kramer. Socialism is the theory of organization where the public owns the factors of production for the good of everyone. To prepare and serve a ham sandwich, a poor pigs life must be sacrificed to serve the majority of the consumersthat is utilitarianism. The black book of communism crimes, terror, repression.
I do not really see the difference between the statements our aim should be to maximize eudaimonia and communism is a utilitarian system that maximizes eudaimonia. Marx this essay is intended to demonstrate that utilitarianism is a bourgeois ideology incompatible with and hostile to communism. To marxists, the acceptable action in class morality is whatever it takes to accomplish the ultimate goalnamely, a classless communist society. The authors did such a bad job they were forced to admit it and print a retraction. Such a thing doesnt even enter in the mind of somebody. Jacob heilbrunn wall street journal the black book of communism, which is finally appearing in english, is an extraordinary and almost unspeakably chilling book. Criticism of communism can be divided into two broad categories. They said the changes would be made in the next edition. Utilitarianism suggests the maximizing of utility, but does not prescribe what the utility function must be. The first printing sold out in a matter of weeks, and the.
A utilitarian philosophy is used when making social, economic or. The black book of communism, written by stephane courtois has been called into question on multiple different grounds. Communism from latin communis, common, universal is a philosophical, social, political, economic ideology and movement whose ultimate goal is the establishment of a communist society, namely a socioeconomic order structured upon the ideas of common ownership of the means of production and the absence of social classes, money and the state communism. Few, if any, have read the book, the black book of communism, and even if you pointed out this book, along with other historically accurate books. The most blatant example is karl marxs own criticism of utilitarianism. Let me explain to you based on my modest and humblest understanding by using an analogy of ham sandwich and egg sandwich. The obvious criticism is that the greatest happiness of the greatest number of people described as the yardstick of utilitarianism might entail some egregious injustice on a minority or individual. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Some deny that marx has or can have any ethical theory at all. Some critics have objected to the books depiction of communism and nazism as being similar, others have criticized the approach the book takes to assigning blame of deaths, and still others, most notably j. The biggest lies ever concerning communism are debunked. It originated at the time of the most intense activity of the industrial revolution, and attempted to curb some of its worst abuses. Full text of the black book of communism internet archive. It could be argued that marxism is not a science and that communism is not an absolute truth, so therefore theres nothing to justify what has been done in its name, yet firstly, whether or not marx was right is separate debate, and secondly, even if marx was proven wrong.
Some critics consider socialism to be a purely theoretical concept. Benthams form was later named as act utilitarianism this is because each action is judged individually and in isolation by using the hedonic calculus it is known as strong utilitarianism because the principle must be applied in every situation no matter what, and an action is only good if it produces a greater balance of pleasure over pain. Arch getty, for its lack of distinction between famine deaths and intentional deaths. Communism controls the flexibility of production and there isnt any unemployment. Capitalism, utilitarianism, socialism, communism, anarchism. The book has evoked a wide variety of responses, ranging from enthusiastic support to severe criticism. Utilitarianism is an egalitarian theory, however, because the interests of everyone count equally. Peasants often resisted communism more fervently than any group.
The black book of communism stephane courtois, nicolas. Utilitarianism has a hedonistic psychological ground whereas communism if by that you mean marxs theory stays on logicaldialectical basis. Of bentham, he wrote in capital, bentham is a purely english phenomenon. Buy the black book of communism crimes, terror, repression book online at best prices in india on. The black book of communism, one of the largest most blatant distortions of history. What are some criticisms towards ethical utilitarianism. Under utilitarianism, the moral quality of an action depends on its consequences for all the parties it affects, including the actor. What is the difference between utilitarianism and communitarianism. It is a measure of the success of the class struggle that the reactionary intelligentsia felt compelled to write an 854 page book touching on the death toll of communism.
The black book of communism gives a balance sheet of our present knowledge of communisms human costs, archivally based where possible, and otherwise drawing on the best secondary works, and with due allowance for the difficulties of quantification. As nouns the difference between utilitarianism and capitalism is that utilitarianism is philosophy a system of ethics based on the premise that somethings value may be measured by its usefulness while capitalism is politicsuncountable a socioeconomic system based on private property rights, including the private ownership of resources or capital, with economic. So what is our authors rationale for throwing away their old convictions. The authoritative black book of communism estimates the total at 80 to 100 million dead, greater than that caused by all other twentieth century tyrannies combined. Maos great leap forward needed only two years to destroy tens of millions of peasants. Totalitarianisms central feature is a state that desires total control and assumes the right to impose that control at any cost. The black book of communism has all the hallmarks of such a shift of allegiances. Le livre noir du capitalisme the black book of capitalism is a 1998 french book published in reaction to the black book of communism.
It is a major study that deepens our understanding of communism and poses a philosophical and political challenge that cannot be ignored. Criticisms of communist party rule is an article dealing with. Under this, government should try to make the most. He is very critical of the two pioneering utilitarians, bentham and mill.
As nouns the difference between communism and utilitarianism is that communism is any political philosophy or ideology advocating holding the production of resources collectively while utilitarianism is philosophy a system of ethics based on the premise that somethings value may be measured by its usefulness. Full text of the black book of communism see other formats. The fraudulent death tolls contained in the book are the single most quoted anticommunist source in the world. This number is accumulated from more than 10 different nations and various movements around the. Utilitarianism is not an altruistic theory in that it does not require individuals to ignore their own interests.
Brenkert, university of tennessee the relation of marxs writings to ethical theory has been viewed in a variety of different ways. The greatest happiness for the greatest number has never been on the communist agenda, it has never been the justification for communism. However you define a utilitarian, marx was not one. Distinguishing which is more illegible to understand and helpful for the society to function is for the society itself.
The book not only bashes socialism and makes it out to be worse than fascism, it outright tries to portray fascism as a good thing. Overall, somehow or another, the black book of communism has managed to raise the debate one notch. Already famous throughout europe, this international be. Some critiques are not directed toward socialism as a system, but rather toward the socialist movement, parties or existing states. Out of this system grew the philosophy of utilitarianism. I will tell you something of which may be laughable for you. The primitive difference begets several different consequences at the politicalpractical level, doesnt matter how close certain concepts of the two doctrines can seem. The black book of communism begins to show us that totalitarianism is totalitarianism, whether we call it fascist, communist or some other name. Black book puts to rest the odious fiction that has softened communisms image for so long.
I have noticed a lot of marxists are influenced by some consequentlialist thought, so people unfamiliar with the nuances of these subjects may mistakenly conflate that with utilitarianism. So does utilitarianism in the capitalist context actually encourage greed. Crimes, terror, repression jeanlouis panne, andrzej paczkowski, karel bartosek, jeanlouis margolin, nicolas werth, stephane courtois, mark kramer, jonathan murphy, mark kramer on. Crimes, terror, repression is a 1997 book by stephane courtois, nicolas werth, andrzej paczkowski and several other european academics documenting a history of political repressions by communist states, including genocides, extrajudicial executions, deportations, killing populations in labor camps and artificially created famines.
980 1282 1348 691 1266 1055 1073 351 432 414 1078 231 1218 167 1363 1070 1052 106 1325 294 1270 434 444 147 681 134 354 798 1039 584 401 951 833 1071 1303 718 1037